MANILA — Vice President Sara Duterte-Carpio’s defense team drew sharp objections from senator-judges and House prosecutors Thursday after using video clips from former Chief Justice Renato Corona’s impeachment trial to suggest political persecution in the Vice President’s own proceedings.
The presentation, which featured the late senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago, Corona and former president Rodrigo Duterte, was criticized as irrelevant and an attempt to sway the impeachment court through emotion rather than evidence.
The controversy erupted as the Senate impeachment court resumed hearings following a break for the Philippines’ hosting of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations Summit.
Defense lawyer Mark Vinluan presented lawyer and certified public accountant Rainer dela Fuente, an anti-money laundering compliance practitioner, to challenge the prosecution’s interpretation of financial transactions involving Duterte-Carpio and her husband.
During questioning, the defense played footage of Santiago criticizing prosecutors in Corona’s 2011-2012 impeachment trial over the withdrawal of five of eight impeachment articles.
The defense sought to draw parallels with Duterte-Carpio’s case, in which prosecutors withdrew three of four impeachment complaints, leaving a single charge involving alleged unexplained wealth.
Sen. Erwin Tulfo questioned the relevance of the footage, likening the presentation to a movie screening, while Sen. Panfilo Lacson stressed that Santiago’s remarks concerned an entirely different impeachment case.
The defense also showed Corona becoming emotional while defending himself, prompting Sen. Raffy Tulfo to point out that the former chief justice was ultimately convicted for failing to fully disclose his assets and bank deposits.
Another clip featured Rodrigo Duterte discussing the possibility of impeaching then vice president Leni Robredo.
Vinluan subsequently asked dela Fuente whether information from the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) could be weaponized for political purposes.
“It can, the possibility is still there,” dela Fuente replied.
The witness cited provisions of the Anti-Money Laundering Act prohibiting the use of AMLC information for political persecution.
House prosecutor Chel Diokno of Akbayan Party-List challenged the videos’ relevance, arguing that statements from deceased personalities could not be subjected to cross-examination and should not influence the court.
Diokno characterized the presentation as an emotional appeal rather than evidence addressing the allegations against Duterte-Carpio.
Sen. Risa Hontiveros likewise questioned the use of recordings featuring Santiago, Corona and Rodrigo Duterte, saying the individuals could no longer be questioned by senator-judges.
The defense also questioned the confidentiality of AMLC reports and bank documents involving Duterte-Carpio and her husband.
However, Sens. Raffy Tulfo and Francis Pangilinan maintained that the issue had already been resolved, emphasizing that the impeachment court was exempt from laws protecting the confidentiality of such records.
The dispute comes amid allegations that Duterte-Carpio accumulated P817.87 million in supposedly undeclared wealth between 2022 and 2025, based on a forensic financial report prepared by analyst Alexander Cabrera using records presented during the trial.
Separately, the AMLC received reports covering P4.4 billion in transactions linked to the Vice President and her husband./PN





